Baroque Explorations: 2008

Baroque Explorations

Notes on the Writing Life

Sunday, December 28, 2008

Fact and Fancy

I read the paragraph below on a blog:
"Over 300 years ago, King Louis XIV of France asked Pascal, the great philosopher of his day, to give him proof of the existence of
miracles. Without hesitation, Pascal answered, "Why, the Jews, your Majesty. The Jews." History does not tell us the king's reaction to this proof, but we do know exactly what Pascal meant by his answer, because he explained it clearly in his masterwork, Pensees. He states that the fact that the Jewish people had survived even to his day was proof enough for him that miracles occur."
I wondered if there was truth to this story: it seemed a bit too tidy. I posted my question to a Yahoo group on Louis XIV, and the wonderful Gary McCollim, a Sun Court historian, posted this reply:
I do not know whether the king and Pascal ever had such a conversation. However, I can add a few facts to help us decide whether the two men ever met. Andre Le Gall's biography of Pascal mentions no such meeting.

Pascal died in August 1662 when Louis XIV was about to turn 24 years old.

Pascal converted to Jansenism in 1647. Jansenism was condemned by the papacy on several occasions starting in 1653.

There was a lot of debate over whether what the Pope condemned was actually in the ideas of Jansenius or among the beliefs of the Jansenists. Louis XIV hated the Jansenists because he saw them as schismatics and promoters of disorder. He says in his memoires that Cardinal Mazarin told him to crush the Jansenists. Louis saw them as part of the Fronde rebellion because they supported Cardinal de Retz against the crown.

Pascal would publish 18 Provincial Letters under a pseudonym between 1656 and 1658, These letters were condemned by the Church and the crown in 1658. The letters were a defense of Jansenism against the so-called attacks of the Church.

Pascal became convinced that miracles do indeed take place in 1657 when his niece was cured of a painful eye infection after touching what was believed to be a thorn from Christ's crown of thorns.

In order to resolve the situation in 1661, the clergy of France with the help of the faculty of the University of Paris came up with a formluary that asked the signatories to sign supporting the Pope's condemnation of five suspected tenets of Jansenism. Pascal at first opposed signing such a document because it would make the signers appear to agree that these states were in fact part of the Jansenist doctrine, but he later relented.

Did Louis XIV ever meet Pascal? It does not appear to be likely, bur it is difficult to prove a negative.

Gary McCollim
I am, as always, impressed by Gary's scholarship. He is a fastidious and careful historian; his factual record helps separate fact from fancy.

Do I think Louis XIV met Pascal? Unlikely, yes, and even more unlikely that they would have had the conversation cited, in my view.

Saturday, December 27, 2008

Wonders and Marvels: Bone Magic

Historian Holly Tucker writes a wonderful blog on the 17th century: Wonders and Marvels. Today I'm the guest, and I wrote about Bone Magic, a 17th century ritual used to tame unruly horses:
Wonders and Marvels: Bone Magic

Thursday, December 25, 2008

Nicolas Bonnart

I've been having a wonderful time exploring images on Google. These late-17th century paintings by Nicolas Bonnart are a treasure.



(Left) The Perfumer's Costume. (Middle) Cleante Dressedsed as a Cavalier. (Right) Lady of Quality Playing the Guitar.



(Left) Gentleman Playing the Angelica. (Middle) Lady Taking Coffee. (Right) The Innkeeper (an allegorical costume design).




(Left) The Summer Sword Dress, 1675. (Middle) The Midwife. (Right) A Woman Seated on the Grass.



(Left) A Nursemaid with Child. (Middle) The Summer City Dress, 1678. (Right) Polichinelle (an Italian comedy figure).




(Left) The Banker, 1678. (Middle) The Dancing Master. (Right) Allegory of Spring.

Sunday, December 21, 2008

Jeff Koons at Versailles

The current uproar over the Jeff Koons pop-art exhibition at Versailles has been topped this week by an official letter to French President Sarkozy from Charles-Emmanuel de Bourbon-Parme, a direct descendent of Louis XIV.

There are, according to Wikipedia, 121 in the line of succession to the throne, and Charles-Emmanuel ranks 65 on the list of official descendents. The current pretender to the throne is Louis Alphonse, Duke of Anjou.

(Thanks to Carolyne Lee's blog post on the exhibition at Versailles.)

I am reading, right now, a book on theatrical history, and am reminded of the furor over the first performance Molière's comedy "Tartuffe" in 1664 at Versailles. In spite of Louis XIV's personal delight in the play, the King was forced to have it banned due to pressure from the religious right. There would continue to be, at Versailles, a number of "uproars" over the centuries, but few having to do with art.

Sunday, December 14, 2008

History of the sun motif

.
Blog reader Tana Bero wrote that she would like to know more about the sun motif.

In 1653, young Louis XIV, then 15, danced in "Ballet of the Night," costumed as Apollo the Sun god, wearing shoes with huge gilded sun buckles.
It was an allegorical dance which portrayed the young King as the rising sun, dispelling darkness.

Almost ten years later (January 19, 1662), the King danced the same part, dressed as the sun, in an impromptu ballet performed chez Madame, his sister-in-law.
A few weeks later of the same year (February 7, 1662), the Court gathered at the Tuileries palace to see “Hercules Amoureux." The King danced in most scenes, several times appearing as the sun in a golden wig — the symbolism of the sun serving to represent the return of order.

That summer, June 5-6, 1662. A tournament was held in front of the Tuileries. Again, Louis appears as the sun, but this time, for the first time, he used the emblem of the blazing sun on his coat-of-arms (instead of the fleur-de-lis), which won him the name
le roi soleil. (His brother Philippe rode into the lists bearing a shield showing the moon eblazed with the motto, Uno sole minor — "second only to the sun.")

It was an apt symbol for Louis XIV, and from this point on, the sun emblem began to be used everywhere: on furniture, floors, carpets, wrought into gates and grilles, carved into marble vases and into door panels.

Saturday, December 13, 2008

Moonlight

When I crossed our courtyard to my office stairwell early this morning, the full moon was still high in the sky. Its light on the stone columns was ghostly and amazingly bright. I thought, then, of a book I've been reading off and on for a year: At Day’s Close; Night in Times Past, by A. Roger Ekirch. Night — without electricity — was an entirely different experience than it is today. Social excursions could be made if the moon was full and bright; otherwise one bolted the window shutters and doors and prayed to see the dawn. Night was dangerous, and to be feared.

It is difficult to imagine viewing a beautiful sunset and responding with dread. Likewise, it is difficult for us to understand how the need for security — especially for a woman — changed how one acted, restricted ones actions. (This can especially hamper a novelist: how do you manage to get private scenes when a woman is always accompanied?) Women travelling alone sometimes dressed as men: they had reason to be fearful.

Holly Tucker, 17th century historian and author of Pregnant Fictions: Childbirth and the Fairy Tale in Early Modern France, recently sent me this stirring passage from Andrew Hussey's Paris: The Secret History (p. 160):
"The real danger for women in the city were kidnap, rape and forced marriage. It was common for a gentilhomme without a fortune to abduct a widow or young girl from a wealthy family and, in a solitary spot outside the city, marry her under the ordrs of a bought priest. The prelude to this act was often rape, which destroyed the last shred of respectability for the unfortunate woman. The practice was widely accepted among the aristocracy. The fathers of these abducted brides usually coughed up some sort of dowry and, although principally devised as a money-making racket, many marriages strangely flourished from these unlikely beginnings."
One of the lessons of history is that things have changed.

Monday, December 8, 2008

Spanish Fly

The Bastille Archives are a treasure trove of information. This morning I discovered, for example, in a report by Reynie, the police chief, that the "love powders" being delivered by Voisin to Montespan — for use on the King (or perhaps by Montespan herself?) — contained "des cantharides," more commonly known as "Spanish Fly."

Ah
. Love powders indeed.

Cantharidin powder was used in aphrodisiac sweets called pilles galantes, or pastilles de Richelieu, because the Duc de Richelieu offered them to his mistresses. In the 18th century, Madame du Barry, King XV's mistress, was said to have called them pastilles de sérail (pastilles of the seraglio), taking them herself or giving them to young women to prepare them for amorous duty with the ageing King. In 19th century France, it was commonly available as philtre amoureux or love philtre. Sometimes the powder was dissolved in alcohol, producing a tincture.

"Before, she was common talk; now, none dare say, cantharides can stir her." — 1611, Beaumont

"Spanish Fly" is in fact neither Spanish nor a fly, but a "blister beetle" which has a chemical in its body that's an irritant. When rubbed on the body it produces blisters (hence its name). When the dried, crushed body of the beetle is eaten, it causes inflammation of all the organs of the genital tract, including the genital organs. This gave rise to the believe that it was an aphrodisiac and could be used to treat impotence.

However, the swelling induced could be extremely painful, and the dose required to produce swelling was close to fatal. (
A dose of only 10 milligrams can kill.) In women the powder could cause painful contractions of the uterus, and for this reason it was used to induce abortions.

It also caused number of medical problems. It could cause permanent renal damage, for example (which casts suspicion, in my mind, on the King's renal fistual later in his life).
Over time, the kidneys would be damaged. The user (or, rather, abuser) would experience a dull, heavy pain in the loins, and have a constant desire to urinate (but passing only a small amount of blood-stained urine). After some time, convulsions occur followed by death within twenty-four hours.

The history of its use is long. The Roman empress Livia (58 B.C.-A.D. 29) slipped it into the food of members of the imperial family to cause them to commit sexual indiscretions that could later be used against them. In 1772, the Marquis de Sade gave sweet aniseed balls laced with Spanish Fly to prostitutes, who began to have uncontrollable vomiting, and died in agony a week later. In 1953, a fisherman accidently killed himself by pricking his thumb with a fish hook that had been dipped in a tincture containing the powder (which he believed would attract fish). The following year a man was convicted of killing two women by giving them coconut candies with cantharidin in them.
"you whoreson cantharides!" — 1601, Ben Johnson
It had medical uses, as well. Cantharidin powder was believed to cure gout, carbuncles, rheumatism as well as a number of other medical disorders. Today it is used in the treatment of warts and in veterinary medicine in breeding farm animals.

Blister beetles would have been easy to acquire. They often swarm within alfalfa fields, and most often in fields next to weedy areas that are likely to contain an abundance of grasshopper eggs, on which they feed. They also can be found clustered on an evergreen shrub used for hedges, or olive, ash or elder trees. By tradition, the beetles were gathered before sunrise while unable to fly. The collectors veiled their faces and hands before shaking them down onto cloths laid out on the ground. The beetles were then dried, and heated until they disintegrated into a fine powder, which has a bight green metallic lustre.

When swallowed, a person would experience a burning sensation in the throat and stomach, have difficulty swallowing, experience nausea and abdominal pain, vomit blood-stained material, feel an intense thirst, and have diarrhoea with traces of blood and mucus. Sometimes blisters form on the mouth and parts of the intestine.

All in all: not very romantic!





Sunday, December 7, 2008

Bastille Archives

I have been delving into the Affair of the Poisons again, trying to understand the roles of Athénaïs (Madame de Montespan), and her maid Claude des Oeillets in this sordid affair. In sorting it out, I first revisited Anne Somerset's The Affair of the Poisons; Murder, Infanticide & Satanism at the Court of Louis XIV, an excellent book, in my opinion, with clear and specific references.

Most of Somerset's information is from the Bastille Archives, where one can read the word-by-word interrogations of the hundreds of people arrested for poisoning, witchcraft and infanticide. Through the French on-line library — Gallica — I've been able to download all seven volumes, and so have them on my computer. In this way, I've been able to check Somerset's specific references by going to the volume and page cited.

This, in turn, led me back to Gallica, on a search for more information about Villedieu, Claude's friend who was convicted and imprisoned in a convent for the rest of her life. I was initially intrigued because I thought this might be Mlle. de Villedieu, a writer of erotic semi-autobiographical fiction, but no: it's Madame de Villedieu, the spurned wife of the man the erotic novelist ran off with. Tant pis.

Madame de Villedieu's testimony indicates that she'd known Claude for some time, and that Claude had been to see the "witch" Madame Voisin at least fifty times. What strikes me as curious is that Madame Voisin insisted — even under horrifying torture, even when her death by burning was certain — that she'd never laid eyes on Claude, much less on Claude's employer Athénaïs (the Sun King's mistress and mother of several of his children). Why the protection? Voisin was spilling the beans on practically everyone else at court — why not a word about Athénaïs and her maid?

Or is Villedieu's testimony false? That seems unlikely to me, although she might well have been quite angry to find herself in prison while her friend Claude remained free, courtesy of the King's protection.

It's quite an intriguing Affair, and I suspect I'll be lost in it for some time.

-----
Afternote (after indeed much more research): Madame de Villedieu was not, in fact, speaking of Claude, for she described her as someone completely different.

Thursday, November 20, 2008

A mystery solved

A French article, "On a retrouvé le mythique 'diamant blue de la couronne'," solves the mystery of a beautiful blue diamond purchased by the Sun King, which was stolen in 1792. It has been identified as the "Hope" diamond in the Smithsonian Institute in the U.S.

Originally the diamond, known as the "Rose of Paris," was purchased by Louis XIV. It was stolen during the Revolution and re-sized so that it would not be recognized.

François Farges from the Museum d'Histoire Naturelle de Paris identified the connection to the Hope diamond after his team found the lead copy of the original diamond in the reserve of the museum. "I did not dare believe it. I did not sleep for one week. I woke every three hours to look at the photographs which I had taken. It was too beautiful to be true."

This sketch shows the outline of the original blue diamond, and the smaller Hope diamond within it.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

17th Century authors site

In response to a call for writers who write about 17th century (see my post below), in no time at all a stunning new website has been created: Hoydens and Firebrands. This is a group website of seven authors who write about this fascinating century. (The site isn't official yet — it's still in "beta" — but stay tuned.)

I'm especially pleased because ever since moving from the populated (and popular) 18th century, I've felt somewhat on my own in this amazing century.

Monday, November 17, 2008

Mary Novik Video

I've interviewed Mary Novik before. Here is a video of her, explaining the inspiration for her wonderful novel Conceit.

Monday, November 10, 2008

Medieval Times

One has to go to strange places to find the relics of the past, these days. I went to Medieval Times yesterday, hoping to see jousting by men in armour. There were no men in armour, but I did see jousting, tilting at the ring and a number of other events that would have been enjoyed at the Court of the Sun King. The horses were spectacular — although the moves demonstrated were more to my period than to the medieval era (happily for me).

What was most worthwhile, from a research perspective — because, no doubt, this is a fantasy show — was the falconry event. I followed the Falcon Master out to the arena with the bird on his hand -- holding it much as many a noble man or woman would have done. In the arena the falcon was allowed to fly free, swooping over our heads before "capturing" her prey. These birds were sometimes treasured as much as (if not more than!) children.

Saturday, November 8, 2008

A rare glimpse into the past

This is a rare video clip of Edwardian England (as posted on Jeri Westerson's blog, Getting Medieval). It's certainly not 17th century, but an amazing documentary. Pinch me!

It shows, as we've always suspected, that boys will be boys and girls will be girls, and that humans don't change, whatever the costume.

Friday, November 7, 2008

Fictional biography

I'm reading Madame de Maintenon; The Secret Wife of Louis XIV by Veronica Buckley. I've mentioned this book here before: Buckley was reported to have quoted extensively from a fictional diary of the King. I see no evidence of this yet, so presumably the error was caught before this edition went to press.

I'm finding it an engaging read in spite of the fact that Buckley is predisposed to think very poorly of the King and Colbert. I've previously found Maintenon boring, but this account makes her seem quite interesting. (Quite!) However, I can't really trust this author.

There are small errors in detail — at least I think they might be errors. Buckley mentions Maintenon shopping in boutiques along the Cours-la-Reine around 1660. I'm not sure that there were such things as fashion retail shops at that time. (I'd want to check.) She also mentions tipping a servant with a coin out of a purse. Again, I don't think purses existed as such at the time.

But these are small and unimportant. When we come to Louise de la Vallière, I know the account to be false. Regarding Athénaïs, for example:
"She's desperate to make me fall in love with her," [the King] said to Louise, and they laughed together...
Louis is reported to have said this to his brother, not to Louise (if indeed he said it at all). This account, however, makes for a better story; the so-called non-fictional account is in fact something of a fiction. A good fiction, parsed together out of scraps of fact. Here's another example:
Surprisingly, the normally bashful Louise had declined to shrink away into oblivion, returning from Paris to Saint-Germain without waiting for Louis' permission. "Madame de la Vallière is quite reestablished at court," Madame de Sévigné reported ... . "The King received her with tears of joy ... ."
The quote is correct, but refers to an entirely different episode, that of Louise being coerced to return to the court from a convent.

Examples such as these make me distrust all the other parts of this otherwise delicious biography. When I record notes from this book, I will also note that the source is unreliable.

(Afternote: Gary McCollim, a Sun King scholar, has two excellent posts critiquing the Buckley biography: here, and here.)

Is the 17th century "unpopular"?

This morning author Alison Stuart posted a request on a historic fiction list for authors writing about the 17th century to contact her. "Nothing sinister," she added. "I am just keen to explore an idea about pooling resources to lift the reading public's interest in this fascinating (but 'unpopular') period of history."

Is the 17th century unpopular?

I think so. The Historical Novel Society puts out a review publication, grouping novels by era. The 16th century invariably has a long listing, as well as the 18th and 19th, but the list of novels set in the 17th is noticably short — rarely more than a handful.

Perhaps the question should be: Why is the 17th century unpopular?

I have a theory about this: England in the 17th century was a dire and gloomy place to be (devastating Plague, the Great Fire). Perhaps this has put people off. Curiously, the experience of the 17th century in France was quite different, at least in the second half of the century, when French culture flowered and flourished during the reign of the Sun King.

It is also a period without "a handle": What do we call it? Late Renaissance? Early Modern? It seems to be a period in-between ... and yet this is what makes it so fascinating, in my view.

Wednesday, October 29, 2008

My first guest: Mary Novik

I've decided to "interview" writers of historical fiction about their research — in particular, writers of 17th century historical fiction. My first is the Canadian writer Mary Novik, whose novel Conceit awed me. In the poetry of its prose, it reminded me of Year of Wonders by Geraldine Brooks — high praise indeed.

Conceit is the story of John Donne's delightfully spunky daughter Pegge. I loved the way the novel changed voice — from the point-of-view of Pegge, to that of her mother and father. The details amazed and charmed me. Novik paints a vivid portrait of daily life in the 17th century. In an author's note, she writes: "... after all is said and done, this is my seventeenth century and I have invented joyfully and freely." Yes, but she is modest. I've been immersed in the 17th century for almost a decade, and, in my opinion, she has "created" it beautifully.

Some vivid and charming examples:
"The pimpernel has closed, but the dandelion is still open, so it is between two and three o'clock."

"I progressed cautiously into the salon, for I had discovered that my new farthingale went its own way without my legs if I moved quickly."

"Waiting on the west side of the Fleet, Pegge eyed the naked buttocks hanging down through the privies suspended over the eastern bank."
My questions to Mary were:
"Do you research and then write; do you research as you are writing? What is your pattern? Were there any surprising discoveries?"
Here is Mary Novik's account:
My novel Conceit began with a happy accident. Browsing in a bookshop in England, I chanced upon an erotic poem by John Donne that really intrigued me. Had he written it to the teenaged Ann More? I knew he had eloped with her and then complained, "John Donne. Ann Donne. Undone." I sought out his effigy in St Paul's Cathedral and stared at the smug grin carved into marble. What had happened between that passionate love affair and his death? I learned that Donne's effigy was the only one that survived the Great Fire of 1666. That night, I dreamt that his daughter Pegge was rescuing the effigy from the fire storm in Paul's. That sparked the opening scene of Conceit. Writing it, I looked for witnesses and found that Samuel Pepys, John Evelyn, and others had written dramatic accounts of the fire in their diaries.

Conceit evolved like this, by fits and starts, accidents and dreams. Many of the scenes in Conceit evolved from images or rhythmical phrases that stuck with me. I would write a passage, then run out of steam. To avoid writing, I'd read letters, diaries, or other 17th-century writings, or lie on the floor studying old drawings and maps. A catchy word, a peculiar detail, even a cul-de-sac on a map would send me back to my desk. In one of Donne's letters, he said "Pegge has the pox." I hunted for more about Pegge, but all I could find was church records. Strangely, this made her more appealing and she became the main character of the novel.

Researching events, buildings, and well-known people was easier than finding human details, the grit of life. Far too much came to light about Donne's public side, so I began to imagine his private life. Fortunately, he loved to have his portrait painted. There's a suggestive one of him as a youth--a sexy, brooding portrait of Jack Donne, the ladies' man. A more sober painting shows him as the Dean of St Paul's. His wife long dead, he was by then famous for his sermons. I wanted to get inside that Deanery, to find out what his seven children thought of him, but no biography could put me there. Locating his Will was a breakthrough, because as well as bequests, it listed the contents of the Deanery's rooms. It also mentioned an old servant, Elizabeth, who had looked after his daughters. This was delicious, since I had already invented such a person and named her Bess.

Most of my research was like this, discovering surprising facts, consulting eye-witnesses, and pure serendipity. I suppose this is why it took me seven years to get fully inside the characters, hearing, seeing, and even speaking as they did. Immersed in 17th-century English, I savoured oddball words that have been lost to us today. A happy discovery was that Donne invented the modern meaning of the word "sex." This led me to write a scene in which he gives the word "sex" to Ann on their wedding night, as well as a later one in which his children joke about the innuendos in his love poems.

[Image: John Donne as a melancholy lover, ca. 1595.]

There was one biography of Donne that I did like--the one written by Izaak Walton, the fisherman. This oddity was a treasure-trove. Full of delightful errors and myths, it revealed that Walton had not really known his subject. My Pegge would have been irate at this glorification of her father, who had a generous helping of warts. I tried to usher Walton firmly out the door, but he kept showing up in my novel. He hung about the Deanery, picking up crumbs of gossip to use in his biography. He pandered to the dying Donne, a prelude to writing his famous description of Donne's apotheosis in The Life and Death of Dr Donne.

I drew on my own experiences as well--walks along river pathways and childhood memories of a noisy household with five siblings. Michael Ondaatje said that facts breed and what they produce is fiction. I love that. I suppose if I had to sum up now, I'd say I was seeking verisimilitude, not historical accuracy. I like to think that if someone read a biography of Donne alongside my novel that they wouldn't contradict one another, they would simply reveal different sides of him. But most of all I hope the reader has as much fun reading Conceit as I had writing it.
Read this beautiful, passionate, poetic book!

(More information about Conceit and the 17th century may be found at http://www.marynovik.com.)

Cutting pages

It's thrilling to discover a book with uncut pages. I'm often tempted to leave the book as is — so virginal — but for the rather serious problem that I neet to read it, and cutting, therefore, is necessary.

My most recently acquired book — Molière by Brander Matthews — is uncut. It was only published in 1910, which amazes me. A book with uncut pages seems somehow prehistoric to me, a relic of an age long gone. But of course, it's simply that a great number of changes have taken place in the last century. I'm reading the delightful novel House of Mirth by Edith Warton, and once, on a train, the main character Lily sets to uncutting the pages of a novel, and later -- presumably because she was interrupted in her task (it is time-consuming) — a "uncut book" is on her bedside table.

And now — to cutting the pages. I'm wondering if Lily carried a cutting implement with her in her bag, and what that implement might have been. Certainly, it wouldn't have passed security.

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

Bravo!

I've mentioned Catherine Delors's blog, Versailles and more, on this site: it's brilliant. It has been awarded a prize and I'm joining in on the applause. Bravo, Catherine!

I especially love this in Catherine's response:
Lush, addictive... I am barely legal.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

Cataloguing books

It's that in-between time of year: we're preparing to head south for the winter, to San Miguel de Allende. I've stacks of books in my office that need to be catalogued, and then shelved or put aside to be taken. Each one makes me pause, skim through, long for more time to linger. Leaving books behind is the hardest part of leaving.

One book I must make note of is Maggie Secara's A Compendium of Common Knowledge, 1558-1603; Elizabethan Commonplaces for Writers, Actors & Re-enactors. Although the period it covers is 50 years before my own, and England-based, it has a wealth of useful information about daily life that is applicable. I ordered the print edition, but it is also available for download. I highly recommend it.

Friday, October 17, 2008

I love this blog!

Through LinkedIn.com, I've been introduced to Holly Tucker, a 17th century historian with a speciality in medicine. Sing ye! Her blog — Wonders and Marvels — is both a wonder and a marvel. I will be learning a lot there.

Monday, October 13, 2008

A portrait of Louise?

I recently got an email from someone whose grandmother owns an old painting which is inscribed, on the back, Mlle de Lavallière.



I compared it to others of Louise, and frankly — comparing the eyes, the nose, the mouth — I think it might well be her.


There aren't very many known portraits of Louise, and it's exciting to find what might well be a new image.

Saturday, October 11, 2008

The Princess de Clèves and other stories

I read three (very short) novels by Madame de Lafayette while in Europe — or rather, three novels suspected to have been written by her, since a woman dared not put her name on a work. They were: Princess de Clèves, The Princess de Montpensier, and The Comtesse de Tende. All were illuminating about court life — to a point. The complete absence of children was curious. Overall, I was annoyed with the obsessive romantic interest — it reminded me of Grade Nine. The intense need to conceal emotions as well as the intensity of these "affairs of the heart," these "involuntary passions," was interesting, however.
"... there reigned at court a kind of orderly unrest which made life very enjoyable, but also very dangerous for a young girl."
—The Princess de Clèves
Did love exist within a noble marriage? There seemed to be some contradiction on this point. A mother arranges a marriage for her daughter, believing that she is giving her a husband she could love. Passionate romantic love is assumed to be the province of an extramarital affair, yet sometimes a husband truly loves his wife. (Curiously, the reverse is not the case in any of these stories.)

These are historical novels, and often the known historical record was altered to suit the fiction: time shortened or lengthened, characters changed.

I would not call these works "novels" personally — there were few scenes, and very little dialogue. Rather, they seemed a told account, in the manner of a fable. I was surprised to read in the introduction that The Princess de Clèves is considered the first novel written in Europe. It was published in France in 1678. This must be a very narrow definition of what constitutes a "novel," for the comic novel Don Quixote (Part 1) was published in 1605.

This, from Wikipedia:
La Princesse de Clèves proved that France could actually produce novels of a particularly French taste. The Spanish enjoyed stories of proud Spaniards who fought duels to avenge their reputations. The French had a more refined taste with minute observation of human motives and behavior. The story was firmly a "novel" and not a "romance": a story of unparalleled female virtue, with a heroine who had had the chance to risk an illicit amour and not only withstood the temptation but made herself more unhappy by confessing her feelings to her husband. The gloom her story created was entirely new and sensational.
As an aside, it is said to be possible that The Princess de Clèves was possibly written by Ségrais (a man) or was a group project. My feeling is that the parts of the novel that concern emotions are very much the same voice of the other two novels — that of Madame de Lafayette, in short. Now and then there is a chunk of text inserted that is entirely not in keeping with that voice: long, factual, historical accounts. For these, I suspect a man's hand.

Sunday, September 7, 2008

La Grande Mademoiselle

I'm currently researching the life of La Grande Mademoiselle — it's dramatic, brave, and sad. Today, I found this wonderful summary of her life on the net, along with a number of excellent links.

This is an etching from La Grande Mademoiselle by Barine (in translation). The transparent clothing, the naked breast, the military helmet over the ringlets — all very curious.



And here's another image, displaying her proud "royal" nose, so similar to that of the king:

Friday, September 5, 2008

Paper dolls


I love this: Louis XIV and his Court: Paper Dolls, by Tom Tierney.

Sunday, August 24, 2008

The new face of Gallica

Gallica, the on-line French national library, has been offering digitized books on-line long before Google Books did. It was astonishing to me what I could find there, but the site tended to be somewhat quirky. (At one point I was under the impression that the downloads were not available on the weekends.) And it was always entirely in French. Now they have a new, slick interface and an English version: I'm amazed. I had read some time back that they protested Google Books, and perhaps this overhaul is their way of getting a competitive edge. Whatever the reason: bravo!

Sunday, July 13, 2008

The Hour of our Death

I have a number of new research books, and a few nights ago I began reading The Hour of Our Death; the Classic History of Western Attitudes Toward Death Over the Last One Thousand Years by Philippe Ariès. [Trans. From the French by Helen Weaver. Barnes & Noble; New York; 1981] Immediately I got up to look for a highlighter and pencil. This book is going to be fruitful.

One thing I found of interest was this statement:
“People lost consciousness frequently in those days, and even rough warriors, fearless and brave, swooned on every occasion. This emotional susceptibility on the part of men lasted until the baroque period. It was not until the seventeenth century that it became important for the male to master his emotions.” (page 6)

However, I’ve noticed that even in the baroque and even into the late 18th century, men were a lot more emotional than we’re accustomed to seeing them today. Louis XIV wept publically on a number of occassions. Politicians in debates during the French Revolution would break into tears (while declaiming that women were too emotional to vote).

Why was it different then? Why has it changed today? It’s a subject that puzzles me.

One simplistic theory I have is that history progresses as a human being progresses. The Middle Ages, for example, strike me as child-like. There was little self-consciousness about nudity, for example, in the way that very young children can be indifferent. Sometimes the way people acted during the baroque period reminds me of Grade Nine: cliques, petty squabbles. I want to say, “Oh, grow up!” The Napoleonic Era is more like a twenty-year-old, passionate and self-righteous.

And, given all that, what are we now?

Beliefs: that the dead are always present, but that they are only visible to those about to die. (page 7)

I find this sweet and comforting.

Signals of death:
The tolling of a bell that rang all by itself.
Three knocks on the floor.

Then, as now, there was a difference between what the literati believed, and the beliefs of the common people.

Unlike today, where we take great pains to deny that death is imminent, in the past it was considered important for someone to know that he or she was about to die. Sometimes a warning or premonition was taken to an extreme, and the dying person would hasten to arrange a funeral, have the house draped in black, Masses said ahead. And then die on the day and at the hour indicated! (page 9)

Unlike today, to avoid death’s warning was to make oneself ridiculous.

It was considered natural for Death to announce his arrival, so Death should not be sudden: mors repentina. If there was no warning, the natural order of things had been violated (and perhaps considered the wrath of God). Therefore, a sudden death was regarded as shameful. “A vile and ugly death.” Frightening, “a strange and monstrous thing that nobody dared talk about.” There was even debate about whether someone dying alone and suddenly should even be buried in a cemetery.

Another twist: if killed by a criminal: the victim was dishonored, compared to someone who died while committing adultery or playing a pagan game (i.e. any game other than a knightly tournament). The victims of a murder might receive a Christian burial, but would be fined. Even King Henri IV, who died as a result of a knife attack, was not exempt:
“In their funeral orations for Henri IV, preachers felt obliged to exonerate the king from the ignominious circumstances of his death under Ravaillac’s knife.” [page 12]
This is a long, detailed book, and endlessly fascinating. I'll be with it for some time.

Wednesday, May 7, 2008

Top ten research sites

I'm pleased to be a guest blogger on Madam Mayo today, listing my five top historical research sites, and why.

Tuesday, April 29, 2008

Sun King's fictional diaries mistaken for real

According to an article in the Guardian today (see link below), biographer Veronica Buckley, in her book Madame de Maintenon: The Secret Wife of Louis XIV, quotes from French historian François Bluche’s Le Journal Secret de Louis XIV throughout, assuming that the journals are real. They are not, and although at first I read them with the excitement of discovery, it didn’t take me long to deduce that they had to be fiction, so I’m surprised by her costly and embarrassing error. Buckley is the author of Christina, Queen of Sweden, a respected biography, and I can only imagine how painful this must be.

However, to be fair, she’s not the only one. I’ve read an academic thesis that cited Le Journal Secret as a primary source. Even so, how could this have happened — especially given that Le Journal Secret has tell-tale factual errors? Was Buckley’s work not being checked by historians?

I’d like raise yet another question: how could Bluche himself have made so many errors? He is prominent in the field, a respected historian. My suspicion is that he didn’t have his usual army of fact-checkers for a work of fiction. To give only one example, he claims that the King is present at a wedding on April 15, 1661. The bride in question had left Paris two days before, having been married on the 10th. Because I record facts to a detailed timeline, I caught a number of errors with respect to dates in the work: a wrong day here, a wrong month there, even, in one instance, a wrong year.

For more on this, see Helen Pidd’s article in The Guardian, “Find of Sun King’s secret diaries sounded almost too good to be true. And it was …”

Tuesday, April 1, 2008

Elizabeth, the movie

We went to see Elizabeth last night, and we are glad we did. We may even buy the DVD, to have it at home to watch again. The costuming was spectacular, Cate Blanchett brilliant, the settings and photography fantastic. The script was rarely banal and had some nice subtle touches. But...

But as a researcher into history I had quibbles, the greatest being the portrayal of the Protestants as embracers of individualism and light, and Catholics as in the Dark Ages. They had to delineate the good and the bad in true Hollywood fashion, and the movie is, after all, the story of the war of Catholic Spain against Protestant England, and of course Protestant Elizabeth is the movie's heroine. But my personal impression is that the Protestants were the extremists: no dancing, no festivals, even the celebration of Christmas was outlawed for a time. No frivolity whatsoever. Clothing had to be sober, and in dark colours. Everything so serious. In a Protestant church, the women sat separate from the men and the ministers preached covered.

So that's my main quibble, making Catholics out to be so terribly cult-like and evil. Another is that the men and women were so often alone: this would have been highly unlikely. The scene of Elizabeth and Sir Walter sitting on the floor together drinking wine was hard to believe. I think proprieties would have been observed. Also, was it true that the men picked the women up from the crotch in dancing? Minor things: no bonnet at bedtime. Men jumping overboard to save their lives: surely they would have been jumping to a certain death. Etc. etc. etc.

But other than that, a wonderful movie — a wonderful Hollywood movie.

Friday, March 28, 2008

Excellent videos on Versailles

The website for Versailles now offers excellent short videos on-line — called podcasts — in both English and French.

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

More on (historical) fact and fiction

To quote:
What turns me off from traditional historical writing is the distance from which the story is told. When I pick up a book on a historical figure, I want that book to take me into the head space and emotional state of the person I’m reading about. Unfortunately most history books are unable to do that. They are told from the view point of the observer or researcher. And despite the historian’s best efforts to give the protagonist a personality, it always seems to fall short of what the real person must’ve been.
My alternative to history books has become historical fiction. They provide the depth and complexity of character that I crave as a reader and the historical background that I appreciate learning about.
Discovering the past is my main motivation for writing historical fiction. Research sparks me, but it’s only through delving deeply into the day-to-day lives of my characters that I even begin to understand.

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

The fuzzy line between fact and fiction

It disturbs me that “fiction” is getting such a bad rap in the U.S. press, that publishers feel they can’t market a novel, but that a “true” story is okay, that readers hunger for “truth” and will pay for it.

Since when has memoir been held to documentary standards? Memoir is a story created from life. I write historical fiction, and in delving into the research, I’ve come to see quite clearly that historians write fiction, as well. The line between fact and fiction is fuzzy, always, and I don’t understand this urge to nail it down. Facts can be misleading, and fiction can be revealing.

Story is how we explain the past—our history—to ourselves. Story is a powerful tool, and it is story that sets us apart from the world of animals (at least insofar as we know!).

Yet I’m guilty myself, I know. I love that “wow” moment when reading historical texts, thinking: Imagine—this actually happened. I think the issue is not whether something is true or false, but the understanding, the contract that is created between the author and reader. The outrage is: “We have been misled.” Frey’s memoir was more fiction than fact, but was marketed as fact. Even so, I have trouble understanding the furor.

One of my first historical reveries was brought on by a diary I read of a Quaker young woman in 18th century England. I was swept away by this “true” account. On my next trip to London, I researched her life; it was there that I learned that the diary was fiction, a novel. I felt disillusioned, let down, but then thought: “What a good novel.” For it drew me into the world of the past in a very real way—and that’s what fiction can do that fact cannot.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

The beauty of ancient texts

This blog, BibliOdyssey, is a wonderful compendium of visuals from old texts. Delicious browsing.
image