Baroque Explorations: 2010

Baroque Explorations

Notes on the Writing Life

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Furor over Not-Quite-Public Transit in 17th century Paris

.
Searching for a mention of my heroine's mother in La Muze Historique, a 17th century news/gossip-sheet in rhyme (!), I came upon, quite by accident, an interesting account of an early transport system in Paris. Bear with me, for this is rather fun ...

In January of 1662—a winter of severe cold and famine—three noblemen applied for a patent allowing them to run carrosses (enclosed coaches) on defined routes across Paris. They proposed to charge 5 sols for the entire route, less proportionately. (A pound of bread cost about half a sol, so this was roughly—very roughly—equivalent to ten pounds of bread.) Their intention was to provide transportation for those who did not have the means to hire a chaise or coach. Vehicles would be stationed at convenient spots, and scheduled to run a specific times, empty or not. In short: a bus system.

The Excluded
Permission was granted, but with the puzzling qualification that the carrosses could not be used by soldiers, pages, servants in livery, workmen or labourers. Was this to ensure that the conveyances would appeal to the middle class? I suspect so.


(Above: a French carrosse. The carrosses used for transit were also pulled by two-horses, but seated six, according to this source, or eight, according to another—so it may have been bigger. Each coach was numbered on the side with one to four fleurs-de-lis and showed the Paris arms and blazons on the panels.)

The entrepreneurs tested the strength of two horses for two days mid-February, starting at 6:00 a.m. and making four routes before 11:00, and four more between 2:30 and 6:00.

The test was apparently passed, for two months later, seven vehicles began on March 18, running from Porte St. Antoine to the Luxembourg (the route laid out on placards). But the populace—the excluded impoverished, I suspect—followed behind hooting, violently dissatisfied. It was not a successful first run.

The Affair of the Coaches
The experiment was put off, and two months later The Affair of the Coaches (as it was called) was launched yet again on May 20, Saturday, before 7:00 a.m. "with an éclat and a pomp quite astonishing." The difference, this time, was the pomp, but also the threat: accompanying the coaches at each end of the route were two commissaries in robes, four guards, and about two dozen archers and horsemen.

When everything was ready, the Commissaries "exhorted the bourgeois to render it every assistance, and threatened the lower class of people that if the slightest insult was offered, the severest punishment should follow—and this they said de la part du Roi."

As for éclat...
As for éclat, the coachmen were given capes (casaques) in the colours of the King, with the royal and city arms embroidered on them.  With a guard in each coach and archers and horsemen stationed all along the route, the first coach set out, to be followed by the next at 15 minute intervals. (The process was mirrored at the opposite end of the route.)

The day went off without "the slightest disorder," no doubt thanks to the guards, archers and horsemen.  It had become, instead of a riot, an Event. Crowds gathered to watch the coaches pass and little work got done.

The first hitch
The next day, there were "even many women among the occupants"—but by the afternoon there was such a press of a crowd that people couldn't get near.

"...a number of persons assemble to take their places, and, on the arrival of a coach, find it full. This is provoking; but they console themselves by thinking that another will arrive in a quarter of an hour; however, when the second comes, it is full also..."

Sound familiar?

Soon after, two more routes were added. When the service began to be used by auditors, councillors and courtiers going to the chatelet and the palace, the price was raised. The same system was instituted in St. Germain, where once King Louis XIV rode on one. Over the course of a few years, however, the enterprise was discontinued.

The quotes above are from a letter by Madame Perrier (Pascal's sister) to Arnauld de Pomponne on Sunday, May 21, 1662, from Paris (with a footnote by her brother Pascal, who is credited with creating the system).


*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Sunday, November 28, 2010

Madame de Montespan: her haughty side

.
Jordan, a reader of this blog, noted about the portraits of Madame de Montespan (see my blog below):
"The only three Montespan portraits, in my own opinion, that do justice to her famously "haughty" appearance can be seen by following links. As Sandra mentioned in her original post, it's interesting to note how well-fed Athenais seems in some of them."
Here are the images:


This first one is by an unknown artist. Her eyes, as mentioned before, are unusual, slightly protruding—and yes, as Jordan points out, there is something haughty about her.

The second one, a miniature by Jean Petitot, is clearly the image of a "robust" voluptuous woman with a slightly aloof expression. (The site suggests that it might also be the image of Queen Marie-Thérèse, but that I seriously doubt.)


The third one, also a Petitot image, is especially interesting to me:


(Note: this is an iStock photo which I paid for the right to use.)

Given Montespan's slightly protruding eyes (a symptom of Grave's disease), her emotional unsteadiness as well as her weight problem later in life, I can't help but wonder if she had a thyroid problem. Are there any doctors among us?

Thank you, Jordan, for bringing these images to our attention.


*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Images of Madame de Montespan, a seductive angel/devil

.
I've recently discovered Europeana, a great site for text, videos, and images. It's especially great for portraits. Here, for example, are some portraits of Athénaïs de Montespan, some of which I've never seen before:




This one above is credited to Ernest and Mignard. One can see how plump she has become. Here is another by Mignard with a similar theme: 




Athénaïs is often portrayed with her children, no doubt to secure her link to the King. This is another portrait by Mignard: 




And another:




And this one by Charles de La Fosse:




This image by Pierre Gobert is presumed to be of her, and I suspect it likely so:




Her lounging pose was unusual for the time; comfort was a new concept. Here again is a striking study by Nicolas Mignard:




This image of Athénaïs at her chateau at Clagny (Versailles now) is curious: bare legs!



This image, artist unknown (and previously thought to portray Louise de la Vallière) shows a younger Athénaïs with droopy eyes. Might this have been considered the come-hither look?




Here is another, likely even younger portrait, showing her unusual and slightly protruding eyes. 




Here is a fashon plate, dated 1694. I doubt very much that Athénaïs would have been so slender at that time. 



I could easily be on this site all day. 



Sandra Gulland


*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Saturday, November 6, 2010

On the Wild Side

.
Catherine Delors' blog on a Dulwich Gallery art exhibition in London caught my eye: Italian Salvator Rosa (1615 — 1673: bandits, wilderness and magic. Not your usual 17th century fare. 


For example, this haunting portrait, "Lucrezia as poetry":
.

A feast of this artist's striking work can be seen on-line:




*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Tuesday, October 19, 2010

Baroque in motion

.
I've been enjoying—savouring—a gorgeous book all summer: Baroque—Architecture, Sculpture, Painting, edited by Rolf Toman and liberally illustrated with stunning photographs by Achim Bednorz. This book is a visual feast.


The text is illuminating, as well:
"Baroque art tends in the first instance to make a sensual appeal to the viewer: with theatrical pathos, illusionistic devices, and the interplay of different forms the artist seeks to impress, to convince, and to arouse an internal response. This may explain why the style is often experienced as extravagant, showy, or even pretentious." (page 7)
These are often the words used to describe the baroque style: feverish frenzy, ludicrous, bizarre, confused, florid. In short: over the top.

Reading this book, however, I've come to understand that the baroque style was all about the creation of an illusion. Staircases were key for the staging of entrances and exits. Quoting from the German historian Richard Alewyn:
"... spirit of the baroque ... really only came into its own where there was movement." 
"The staircase provided the classic example of the viewer in motion, an essential principle of all spatial art in baroque." (page 10)
In addition to the stunning example shown on the cover above, here are two other examples of baroque staircases:




Imagine an Escher print in three dimensions: imagine walking through it. That's baroque.


*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Sunday, October 17, 2010

Baroque post-modern

.
I begin each day reading the Poetry Daily. Sometimes a poem will catch me, as did the one this morning, "The Dark Figure in the Doorway" by Morton Marcus.


It's a reflective poem about Diego Velázquez's famous painting of the Spanish Infanta, "Las Meninas" —in English, "The Maids"—painted in 1656.




I recommend that you read that poem, but, to summarize, the author talks about the visual tricks in the painting. The Infanta isn't the one being painted, but the King and Queen, reflected in the mirror behind the painter on the left. Only we are the ones standing in their spot; we are the ones the painter in the painting is studying.


The more I learn about Baroque, the more I come to understand its playfulness, it's tricks. As the poet so well put it:
a post-modern  
bit of fun devised 
centuries before  
the modern age  
will have begun.

*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Friday, October 8, 2010

Louis XIV and his heirs: a tragic history


Louis XIV, his son, grandson and great-grandson (tended by his governess), in a painting attributed to Nicolas de Largillière. 


All the King's heirs would predecease him suddenly, one after another. For a clear account, read this blog post by Catherine Delors: here. She has also posted a moving portrait of the surviving child, the future King Louis XV: here.

*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Thursday, October 7, 2010

Le droit du Seigneur—fact or fiction?



[Above, Vaisly Polenov, a Victorian artist, illustrates Le droit du Seigneur—his fantasy of a man offering his daughters to the feudal lord.]


Le droit de seigneur, or the "right of the first night," is commonly understood to be the right of the lord of an estate to take the virginity of the bride or daughter of a serf working his land.

Fact or fiction?
I've read that there was no evidence to support the belief that this was, in fact, a custom of the Middle Ages, that le droit de seigneur was a fiction people had created about the past. (A lively fiction, in fact: Voltaire wrote a five-act comedy based on it, as is Beaumarchais's The Marriage of Figaro and the movie Braveheart, to name a few.)

Therefore, I was rather interested (and surprised) to see reference to it in The Clermont Assizes of 1665, Abbé Fléchier's memoirs. Fléchier was a judge, and his memoir is, among other things, an account of the cases brought before the court.

The case in question had to do with the suit of a certain Madame de Montvallat to separate from her husband. He stood accused, among other things, of exercising "the nuptial right." I quote:
There is a right, quite commonly exercised in Auvergne, called the nuptial right. ... This right originally allowed the lord the right to be present at all marriages among his subjects; to be present at the bedding of the bride...
This usage is no longer current, either because it would be unbecoming for the lords to be present at all the village weddings and to thrust their leg into the beds of all the respectable people who get married, or because the custom was somewhat incompatible with propriety, and exposed gentlemen who had more authority than self-restraint to dangerous temptation when the opportunity was attractive. 
So a substitue was found for this disgraceful ceremony in a pecuniary gratuity, the lords having agreed to receive a more substantial earnest of their rights [i.e. money] and the subjects being glad to buy themselves off from the application of a law so perilous to their honour. 
So: from this I understand that le droit de seigneur had formerly been a ceremonial custom that occasionally invited abuse, but as of this writing—mid-17th century France—the custom was that the serf simply paid the lord to stay away.
Monsieur de Montvallat, however, was persuaded that old customs were the best when a pretty village girl was to be married, and would not give up his rights; and as they had good reason to fear in his case that he might go beyond the limits of a mere ceremony, they thought it best to capitulate and to give him as substantial a present as they could afford. In any case, he claimed this tribute, which often amounted to half the bride's dowry. 
That the lord had a right in some capacity on the wedding night is clear—that it was a right to take a girl's virginity is not. Somewhere in this grey area, truth resides.

For more on this subject, see Wikipedia.

Note: this post was originally published by me on Hoydens and Firebrands.

*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/


Friday, October 1, 2010

Life, Love & Laughter in the Reign of Louis XIV: not a lot of fun

.
.
I was excited to get Life, Love & Laughter in the Reign of Louis XIV by Robert Challe (translated by A. W. Preston)—a novel written during and about the Court of the Sun King—but after 163 pages, I'm calling it quits.

There is something so often adolescent about the culture of the mid-17th century, an obsessive interest in "Does he love me?" "Does she not?" (and "How rich is her dowry?") that I find wearing.

The novel is multi-layered, in the form of (long, tedious) stories revealed during a social gathering.

It opens in a traffic jam, 17th century style.
...a horseman...found himself caught up in one of those traffic congestions which at the time occurred daily at the end of the rue de Gesvres. ...the carriages ... were streaming in from all sides. [His] valet riding behind him was having the same trouble, and both were in danger of being crushed between the wheels of the carriages ... 
Getting from A to B is difficult for any novelist, but Challe gets his hero out of this fix by having people in various carriage offering him a seat. He stood, unsure which offer to choose, when someone called out more loudly than the others. Our hero dismounted and got in the carriage, managing, as well, to get his footman to climb in after him ...
...preferring to risk his horses rather than leave the young fellow in danger.
This mark of a hero impressed onlookers, who call out to their drivers to avoid running down the two horses. (Not because they care about the horses, mind.) The valet then gets back on his horse and follows after his master and the rescuer, leading his master's horse.

I did like some of the details of daily life in the novel, such as in the scene above. I knew carriages often came head-to-head on narrow streets, but I'd never considered that there could actually be a daily traffic congestion much like rush hour.

Other details I enjoyed:
an in-house tailor instantly making a suit of clothes.
a mailman who delivers door-to-door. (I'd be interested to know when, exactly, this began. I imagine his task was not an easy one, since there were no street addresses.) 
a door weighted to close itself.
sending for a sedan chair.
I'm sure I would glean a handful more such details were I to persevere for another 424 pages, but no, I will resist.

This novel is described as a masterpiece: I beg to differ.



Sandra Gulland

*****
Website: http://www.sandragulland.com/
Blog: http://sandragulland.blogspot.com/
Facebook: http://bit.ly/sgullandFacebook
Twitter: http://twitter.com/Sandra_Gulland
Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

Thursday, September 30, 2010

On-line magazine about the reign of Louis XIV

Louis XIV, le destin d'un roi is a stunning on-line publication ...


















I only wish I could actually read it!

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

In search of the perfect curtsey

How to curtsey: It's not as easy as you might think. According to some of the instruction manuals available on Google Books, a curtsey must be made where you stand. You must not lean forward, nor back, but sink down perfectly straight.

You curtsey to show respect to someone; holding your ground shows self-respect.
"A curtsey is in grace what an adagio is in music." — Graham's magazine
Specifically, from The Lady's Book:
Bend your arms gracefully, lightly holding out your dress. 
Bring the front foot into 2nd position.
Draw the back foot into 3rd position behind and then immediately into 4th. 
With the weight on the front foot, bend the front knee and gently sink.
Shift the weight to the back foot and rise. 
Return the front foot to 4th position. 
    There are many forms of a curtsy shown on YouTube, from pert and saucy to a complete collapse onto the floor. Almost all suggest dipping forward, without any self-respect! (Ha--the only one that demonstrates a self-respecting straight up-and-down curtsey is cross-dressing Panty Boy's video.)

    Here is a video demonstrating an early 19th century curtsy, but, as you can see, it's quite a bit different from the curtsy explained above.



    I recall the actresses in an Austen movie being taught to melt into a curtsy.
    "The perfect curtsey is rarely performed in society."
    I can see that! The search for the perfect curtsey goes on...

    Monday, September 6, 2010

    My basic research tools


    I just updated my "Research Tools" page (see tab above). Let me know what you think.

    Sunday, August 8, 2010

    Music and Theatre in 17th century Paris

    .
    This is a wonderful illustrated lecture on music and theatre in Paris during (and after) the rein of the Sun King. I highly recommend it.

    Saturday, August 7, 2010

    Lost and found in 17th century Paris

    .
    I have not been posting, in large part because I've been overwhelmed with research.

    For now, I'll just note what I've found on Hôtel de Mortemart, the Mortemart mansion in Paris. It has been cited as being on rue des Rosiers. I had mistakenly thought that this was rue des Rosiers in the Marais. However, in 17th century Paris, there were two streets of that name. The one that pertains is rue des Rosiers, quatier Saint-Germain. (This discovery, alas, means I will have to make quite a few changes to my novel—see my blog posts here and here.)

    On this 17th century map, you can see its location in the upper right hand corner.


    It's interesting to note that Hôtel de Mortemart isn't even on rue des Rosiers on this map, but on rue Guillaume, then an extension of Rosiers. (Now Rosiers is called rue de Saint-Guillaume.)

    For a fantastic, searchable map of late-17th century Paris, click here.

    Here is a floor plan of the estate:


    The Hôtel was in the parish of the Saint-Suplice church, where Athénaïs, Mlle de Rochechouart-Mortemart was married, and became, forever more, the infamous Madame de Montespan. Just before the wedding, she realized she didn't have a cushion to kneel on. She sent a servant running back to the Hôtel de Mortemart for it. He returned in time, but with a dog cushion.

    Today the Hôtel Mortemart is the School of Political Science (l'Ecole Libre des Science Politiques), 27 rue Saint-Guillaume.

    Some sites claim the hôtel was built in 1663, but another map, one dated 1649, seems to indicate its existence.

    Links:
    History of the Hôtel de Mortemart
    17th century map of Paris (under "diplay" select zoom)
    For a guide to what might be found on any late-17th century Paris street, go to Blégny's Le livre commode des adresses de Paris pour 1692.

    Thursday, July 1, 2010

    iPad: an indespensible research tool

    .
    FYI: I just wrote a blog on The Writing Life on how to use the iPad to read and annotate PDF files: here. This marks a huge step forward for historical researchers. 

    Saturday, June 19, 2010

    Louis XIV at work

    .
    Gary McCollim posted a review of Régner et gouverner: Louis XIV et ses ministres (Reigning and Governing: Louis XIV and his Ministers) by Thierry Sarmant and Mathieu Stoll to the Louis XIV Yahoo group. He went into detail because the book is only available in French. The subject of the king's professional life and his co-workers sounds very interesting. Thank you, Gary (as always)!

    His review: 

    As the Louis XIV group is devoted to Louis XIV and spends most of its time dealing with the king's social life, court life, and the external affairs of France at the time, I thought we might like to look at Louis XIV's professional life. The king worked every day at being king, governing France, making decisions, consulting with his advisors, etc. In the last 25 years of his reign he spent at least six hours every day on affairs of state.

    Sarmant and Stoll have made an excellent attempt to survey the way France was governed from the center during Louis XIV's personal reign. While he became king in 1643 at age 4, Louis XIV did not assume the reins of government until the death of Cardinal Mazarin on 9 March 1661. Thereafter, until his death on 1 September 1715, Louis XIV was his own prime minister. The period between 9 March 1661 and 1 September is called the personal reign of Louis XIV. This book discusses how he actually ran France, his ministers, how they interrelated, and how things worked.

    During his personal reign, there were sixteen men who held the title Minister of State. They were the members of the Conseil d'en haut (sometimes called the Council of Ministers). There were never less than 3 non-royal members of this body and at times as many as five such members. Three of these sixteen men would be disgraced: Foucquet, Pomponne in 1679, and Chamillart in 1709. However, Pomponne was called back in 1691 and died as a minister in 1699. Two of these men retired from the government: Le Peletier who served from 1683 until his retirement in September 1697, he would not die until 1711 and Louis de Pontchartrain who served as a minister of state from 1690 until 1714 when he retired dying in 1727. Four members of this council were surviving when the king died in 1715: Torcy, Desmaretz, Voysin and Villeroy. The other eight died in office.

    Sarmant and Stoll extend the definition of minister beyond these sixteen men to include any government official who met regularly with the king on official business. Thus, they include the Chancellor, the four Secretaries of State, the finance minister, the Surintendant des Bâtiments, the director of fortifications, the members of the Royal Council of Finances, and the intendants of finances who worked under the finance minister. Thus, instead of sixteen men who met with the king, there was a total of 59 men who could be considered ministers by this definition. That number is misleading because several of these men were holdovers from the Mazarin period who were quickly replaced as Louis XIV extended his management of the government. The total is more like 53 men.

    Sarmant and Stoll start with a summary history of the government as it evolved under Louis XIV and then they begin discussing any changes that can be distinguished. For example, the office of Chancellor was reduced in importance under Louis XIV but maintained as the king's legal advisor, the keeper of the seals, the enforcer of censorship, and overseer of all royal academies. Not all Chancellors (there were six men in this office during Louis XIV's personal reign) were members of the Council of Ministers, but they all worked with the king on a regular basis. Louis XIV tolerated Séguier, the man who had been Chancellor since 1633 and was 73 years old in 1661, but he did not replace him immediately. The Chancellorship became a reward for long service to the crown. Séguier's eventual successor, Étienne d'Aligre, was 80 years old when he became Keeper of the Seals in 1672 and 82 when he became Chancellor in 1674. Michel Le Tellier was 74 years old when he became Chancellor in 1677 but he had been a minister of state since the beginning in March 1661.

    Not all four Secretaries of State were equal in authority. The Secretary of State for Protestant affairs (the Religion Prétendue Réformée) never sat on the Council of MInisters and had very little to do after the revocation of the Edict of Nantes. While the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs was always a member of the Council of Ministers from 1661 to 1715 (a total of four men), they were not very important in terms of funding, government contracting, or employment. The Secretary of State for the Maison du Roi and the Navy sometimes sat on the Council of Ministers and sometimes not depending on the personality of the man in the job and the king's opinion of the man which changed. Colbert passed the office on to his son Seignelay who held the office from his father's death in September 1683 until his own untimely death in November 1690. However, Seignelay only joined the Council of Ministers in September 1689. When Louis de Pontchartrain became Chancellor and passed the office of Secretary of State for the Maison du Roi and the Navy to his son Jérôme de Pontchartrain, the latter never sat on the Council of Ministers. Both Seignelay and Jérôme had regular working sessions with the king whether or not they were Ministers of State.

    The most important ministers were the war minister (Secretary of State for War) and the finance minister. They had the most money, the most government contracts, and the most employment opportunities. Indeed, Sarmant and Stoll show that the controller general of finances had the largest central bureaucracy employing almost half the total number of jobs in the central government. When we remember that the finance minister also supervised tax collection in the provinces, all the various treasuries, commerce, etc., we recognize that he was the most important minister. The weakness of his office was that he did not control expenses. In other words, the Secretaries of State, the Chancellor, the Surintendant des Bâtiments could all spend money without asking his permission and simply inform him by requesting that he pay these bills. In short, the finance minister was supposed to pay the bills and was constantly trying to persuade his colleagues to reduce their expenditures.

    Despite their importance, both the war minister and the finance minister were not automatically members of the Council of Ministers. Louis XIV had five different men serve as war minister, but one of them, Louvois' son Barbézieux who served from his father's death in July 1691 until his own early death in January 1701, was never a member of the Council of Ministers, despite the fact that France was at war during 1688-97. Louis XIV had six finance ministers, three of whom became members of the Council of Ministers automatically (Foucquet, Colbert and Le Peletier), but three others had to wait for a short time before entering the council. Louis de Pontchartrain became controller general of finances in September 1689 but did not join the Council of Ministers until November 1690. Chamillart waited from September 1699 until November 1700 and Desmaretz waited from February to November 1708.

    One confusing fact for us is that sometimes these people combined offices. In other words, one man held more than one position. Colbert became finance minister in September 1661, Surintendant des Bâtiments in January 1664, and Secretary of State for the Maision du Roi and the Navy in February 1669 and held all three offices until his death. Louvois became de facto Secretary of State for War (his father held the office simultaneously while letting his son do most of the work) in February 1662 and Surintendant des Bâtiments on the death of Colbert in September 1683 and held both offices until his death in July 1691. Louis de Pontchartrain became finance minister in September 1689 and Secretary of State for the Maison du Roi and the Navy in November 1690 resigning both offices when he became Chancellor in September 1699. Chamillart became finance minister in September 1699 and war minister in January 1701 resigning the former in February 1708 and the latter in June 1709. Voysin became war minister in June 1709 and added the Chancellorship in July 1714. He resigned as war minister after the death of Louis XIV and died as Chancellor in 1717.

    Readers of Louis XIV's instructions for his son the Dauphin will note that there were several noblemen who served as ministers. The king had recommended against adding noblemen to the council but apparently changed his mind as time passed. One anomalous position was that of Chef (Head) of the Royal Council of Finances, a council body that met at least once a week and sometimes more often. This office was created by Louis XIV and was held by three aristocrats during his reign: Nicolas de Neufville, maréchal duc de Villeroy from 1661 to 1685, Paul de Saint-Aignan, duc de Beauviller from 1685 to August 1714, and François de Neufville, maréchal-duc de Villeroy from 1714 until the end of the reign. While the first duc de Villeroy was not a member of the Council of Ministers, his son François was as was the duc de Beauviller from 1691 until his death. (And, yes, the latter marshal duc de Villeroy was the same man who was defeated and captured in Italy in 1702 and then defeated again at Ramillies in 1706. There is a story about how he maintained the king's good opinion when he was such an obvious failure, but I don't know what it is.)

    The last man to inherit the responsibilities of Surintendant de Bâtiments although the title was changed to director general des Bâtiments was Paul de Pardaillon de Gondrin, duc d'Antin from 1708 until his death in 1736. He was an aristocrat as well. Even more important, he was the legitimate son of Madame de Montespan who was made a duke after his father's death. Louis XIV clearly thought well of his former mistress's son. He would work with him weekly on royal buildings, construction, repair, gardens, plants, etc.

    Sarmant and Stoll point to several developments during the reign of Louis XIV. First, the staffs of these ministries tended to grow and to become permanent. In other words, instead of the staffs being replaced as the ministry changed hands as had been the case before Louis XIV, the staffs became permanent and survived the change of ministers. In addition, the staffs became specialized as they grew meaning that one person was charged with certain responsibilities, kept them, and passed them on to his successors. This is the beginning of bureaucracy where the staff becomes the memory of the government. Archives were created. The staffs developed a hierarchy of positions. Some staff members were so important that they could speak for the minister in his absence.

    The strength of this book is the strength of its authors. Thierry Sarmant has written several books on Louvois. Mathieu Stoll did his doctoral work on Claude Le Peletier. Both men were able to incorporate the work of other historians on Pontchartrain and Chamillart. Their weakness is their knowledge of the ministers at the end of the reign.

    Louis XIV inherited a group of administrators from Mazarin, most of whom he kept. He was reluctant to dismiss people possibly because he was an innately polite man who did not want to create difficulties for loyal servants. The rare dismissals were the cause of much gossip at court. Foucquet's disgrace and arrest was the most dramatic of all. Yet, as these men aged and either died or retired, the king had to select people to replace them. His choices were not always good. While several can be discussed, I will limit myself to the most noteworthy bad choice: Michel Chamillart. The king got to know him in the early 1680s because he was a good billiard player with an excellent personality, eager to please, willing to serve, and anxious to be of service. Chamillart rose like a rocket from master of requests to a short tour as a provincial intendant at Rouen before buying a position as intendant of finances in 1690. He became finance minister in September 1699 and war minister in January 1701. Clearly, the king saw him as a potential strong man around whom the government could rally to support the war effort. Instead, Chamillart turned out to be a failure both as war minister and as finance minister. He angered the other ministers by interfering in their affairs. He mismanaged funds and created chaos. He was clearly not competent to the positions he had been occupying. When the generals turned on him in the spring of 1709, Louis XIV was forced to replace his friend.

    At the same time, Louis XIV was forced to take on a finance minister whom he regarded as a crook. Nicolas Desmaretz had worked for his uncle Colbert in the finance ministry for almost twenty years learning every aspect of the kingdom's financial administration. Nonetheless, he was dismissed as an intendant of finances in December 1683 while being accused of taking bribes and kickbacks from government contractors. He would spend the next 20 years out of government as a behind the scenes advisor to the people running France. When Chamillart told the king in 1700 that he was relying on Desmaretz for advice and support, the king is supposed to have said that he (Desmaretz) was a crook (fripon in French). Nevertheless, the king eventually gave Desmaretz a public audience, appointed him director of finances in 1703, and after Chamillart begged to be relieved as finance minister in February 1708, the king was forced to name Desmaretz to the job. Thus, Louis XIV was forced to take on a man who he would rather not have to deal with and then to give up a friend whom he probably wanted to keep.

    Sarmant and Stoll refer to one major incident where all the ministers collaborated together... the policy toward the Huguenots. They paint a picture of the king's determination to end the division within his kingdom and to bring everyone together as good Catholics. All the ministers worked together to support this policy. It was the dream of Catholic France. While particular policies, such as putting dragoons in the houses of Huguenots, were discouraged as going too far, even by people like Louvois, the general policy was to gradually restrict the Huguenots in order to persuade them to become Catholic. In the end, Stoll and Sarmant say Chancellor Le Tellier hurried the process by drawing up the Edict of Fontainebleau that revoked the previous Edict of Nantes in order that he could put his signature on the document before his death. Chancellor Le Tellier, a normally pliant man who was willing to compromise on some issues, did sign the Edict of Fontainebleau on 18 October 1685 and died twelve days later with the satisfaction of having ended the division within France. Stoll and Sarmant discuss this issue to show an example of cooperation and collaboration among the ministers after having discussed their many quarrels over who was responsible for what.

    Thursday, June 10, 2010

    The Fall of the Rebel Angels

    .
    The Fall of the Rebel Angels graces the ceiling of the Royal Chapel of Versailles: stunning.


    "A Chapel for the King" is a special exhibition at Versailles to commemorate the 300th year anniversary of the chapel.

    Catherine Delors just posted some great links about the chapel on her wonderful blog: here.

    Monday, May 17, 2010

    Woman astride on horseback

    .
    I'm still in the midst of a research trip in France (and will have lots to report!), but I just came across this illustration on the Net and wanted to post it here:


    I don't believe I've seen such a clear image of a woman in a gown riding a horse astride. It was published in 1874, but supposedly based on a 14th century manuscript. (Is this possible?) It's not Baroque by any means, but it illustrates how a woman in a gown might manage ... bunched up!
    .

    Thursday, April 29, 2010

    Hola, Hello, Bonjour!

    Here is my latest newsletter: 

    http://bit.ly/SGnewsletter
    And here is the correction I immediately had to send out regarding the date of my reading in Paris. (I've also added some additional details about it.): 
    http://bit.ly/Parisreading

    This is, bien sur, a research trip; I'll have lots to report.

    Come join me in Paris -- why not?

    Wednesday, April 28, 2010

    Standing (dangerously) tall—the Bata exhibit

    .
    While in Toronto, I finally went to the Bata museum, thanks to a note from writer Susan Holloway Scott about a special exhibit: "On a Pedestal: From Renaissance Chopines to Baroque Heels."

    What took me so long? This is a wonderful museum—and this exhibit was fantastic. I had no idea!

    While there, I bought the book by curator Elizabeth Semmelhack about the exhibit — it's full of historical detail.

    I took a pile of notes. Here are some of the things that struck me.


    Slap-soled shoes (shown at left): so named because they make a slapping sound (although I don't quite get that). The flat base was created to keep pointed heels from sinking into the mud.

    The more impractical something was, the higher the class: for example, shoes of white kid were fashionable because they were so easily soiled they implied a life of leisure.

    Chopines (as seen on the book cover above, and which could rise to truly dangerous heights) signified wealth because of the added cost of the expensive material required for the gown to reach the floor. They were especially popular in Spain and Italy, where they were worn by wealthy married women.

    Curiously, at an earlier period in Italy, law required that prostitutes wear chopines. This Bertelli print of about 1588 shows a "cortesan." A flap comes up to reveal her pantalons and chopines. (I was surprised to see pantalons at all: generally, women wore nothing under their skirts.)

    The late 17th century saw a shift toward lower heels. In France, low-platform mules were worn by both men and women "around the house" (read: castle).

    The mules for women were little jewels, gorgeously embroidered and embellished, with pointed toes and slender heels.

    I appreciated seeing the famed red-painted heels of the aristocratic male of that period. It's likely that the paint has faded, but the color looks more like a rich mahogany stain applied to the stacked leather heels. Men's wear tended to have an equestrian function: sturdy, heeled, with broad square toes.

    The Sun King, of course — who was passionate about shoes, among other things — wore pretty mules with bright red heels.

    For more on this wonderful exhibit, see these links: 





    Tumblr: http://sandragulland.tumblr.com/

    image