Baroque Explorations

Baroque Explorations

Notes on the Writing Life

Saturday, April 4, 2009

On enemas ...

.
In an earlier post, I mentioned the false allegations that 1) Louis XIV only bathed twice in his life, and 2) that he had 2000 enemas. Louis XIV did bathe, and although he had a monthly enema and bleeding (believed to expel bad humours), he certainly could not possibly have had 2000.

Gary McCollim, whom I often quote here, has this to say:
Your blog had a note on 30 March about an article claiming that Louis XIV only bathed twice in his life. Stanis Perez who has written a book entitled La Santé de Louis XIV (Champ Vallon, 2007) says that this story is often repeated and is not true (p. 241). The king often bathed on orders from his doctors whenever he was sick. As a youth he often went swimming in the rivers. An bath was installed at Versailles in 1672. I could go on, but the story never dies. His grandfather Henri IV, however, was known to smell like a goat because he rarely bathed but this too might be a false story.

The Enema, by Abraham Bosse

As to the number of enemas the king had, once a month he pris médecin. This meant a bleeding and an enema, what was called a lavement. Lavements were regularly prescribed for various illnesses. As to the number 2000, he would have to have lived 166 years to have one once a month or to have been ill many, many times. Whether he held court or received people or not, he continued his regular activities on these days. Everyone at court knew that the king was taking his medicine on these days.

Saint-Simon tells a story that the duchesse de Bourgogne, the favorite of the king and Maintenon, actually had an enema inserted while she was in the presence of the king and Maintenon. Maintenon was shocked, according to Saint-Simon, but the story left me with the impression that this was some sort of thrill for the youth of that day to see how long they could....... Kind of like kids today and glue sniffing or whatever.
I've read the story of the duchesse de Bourgogne before, and the logistics of the act perplex me. I've also read an account of a woman who liked her lover to give her enemas rather too often. Clearly, there is more to this than we know!

Friday, April 3, 2009

Dream it, and it will come

.
In Mistress of the Sun, I created a locked cabinet in which Athénaïs kept her secrets. Now, it appears, that such a cabinet has been found. "Secrets of rare Louis XIV cabinet unlocked," an article in the U.K. Telegraph, reports the discovery of an ornate cabinet — the only surviving furniture from Louis XIV's Versailles. It is thought to have belonged to Athénaïs because it is decorated with the flower and animal images dear to her. Not many pieces of furniture have survived from the Baroque era, and this is one — made of ebony, marble, and bronze guilt, and encrusted with semi-precious stones — is one of the most opulent.

Most of the drawers are locked, so it was definitely a place where she might have kept something precious ... or secret (such as love powders and spells).


This cabinet, along with other examples of Baroque style furnishings, will be shown in an exhibition at the V&A museum in London April 4 to July 19: Baroque 1620 - 1800: Style in the Age of Magnificence. I wish I could be there, but the V&A website for the show is a visual treat, in an of itself.

(Shown here: a mirror from the V&A show. Mirrors painted with flowers and other motifs were first used in Italy during the Baroque period.)

Thursday, April 2, 2009

A wonderful on-line book store for historians

.
I have had dealings with Susanne Alleyn for some time. I don't know how I discovered Tricolour books, an on-line bookstore specializing in French history, but once there, I was hooked. I found something enticing in every mailing. When the time came for me to sell my own beloved collection of Napoleonic books (to make room for books on the Court of the Sun King), I felt good about going to Susanne.

Since that time Tricolour books has changed: they are now Academy Book Store and have a nifty on-line catalogue. Anyone with an interest in history — French history, in particular, although not exclusively — will find lots there of interest.

When Susanne Alleyn isn't selling books, she's writing them. She's the author of a wonderful series of mysteries set during the French Revolution. Her newest novel is The Cavalier of the Apocalypse, due out from St. Martin's Press July 21, 2009.


Tuesday, March 31, 2009

Portrait of the young Louis XIV

.
Susan Holloway Scott, author of a number of fine novels about kings and their mistresses, brought this portrait of the young Louis to my attention.

As stated on the Philip Mould Fine Paintings website, young Louis succeeded to the French throne in 1643, just before his fifth birthday. In this portrait, painted in that year, you can see the insignia of Kingship: the cordon bleu of the Order of Saint Esprit and the ermine -lined robe embroidered with gold fleur-de-lys.

Susan particularly liked his charmingly ribbon-tied lovelocks. Yes, so very sweet.

Louis — "the God-given" — was adored by his mother, Queen Anne of Austria (who was, in fact, Spanish). She gave birth to him after 22-years of marriage and a number of failed pregnancies. As a child he was described as gentle and docile, according to his confessor, and overly meek and submissive, according to a governess.

For a gallery of portraits of the family of Louis XIV: click here.

Above: Portrait of King Louis XIV as a child (1638-1715) c.1643. Studio of Charles and Henri Beaubrun (1604–1692). Oil on Canvas


Monday, March 30, 2009

A belated update

.
My apologies to the followers of this blog! I've been consumed with details: reconstruction of my website (hence the new look of this blog), getting out a newsletter (you can see it here, on-line), preparing for the release of the paperback edition of Mistress of the Sun, a blog tour, etc.

Not that there hasn't been on-going research — I'll have quite a bit to report in a bit. But for now, a report of Louis XIV in the news. As usual, it's interesting.

•An article on the sun-burst mirror: here. We happen to have a rather old and extremely large sun-burst mirror in our home in Mexico. I find it interesting (if doubtful) that it may have originated with Louis XIV.

•An article claiming that Louis XIV only bathed himself twice in his life: here. Is this true? I doubt it very much.

•This article on the painful medical treatments of the past is quite interesting, but the claim that:
King Louis XIV had over 2,000 enemas during his reign, sometimes holding court while the ceremony progressed.
seems questionable.

And, while I'm in debunking mode, Louis XIV (as well as Napoleon) are credited with saying, "L'etat, c'est moi." Neither has ever been documented.

Bah! Humbug! More anon.

Monday, March 16, 2009

The Queen's Black baby: fact or fiction?

Much has been written about the possibility that Louis XIV's wife, the Queen, gave birth to a black daughter. Needless-to-say, this has given rise to a number of salacious rumours.

Lynn Nottage, author of the play Las Meninas, writes about the spark for the play — read an essay about the African presence in royal families. In this essay was a paragraph that mentioned a romance between an African dwarf and the Queen Marie Thérèse of France. Nottage spent close to eight years researching this and came to the conclusion that the story was true: that in 1661, the Queen had a romance with an African dwarf named Nabo, and gave birth to a child named Louise Marie, "who was whisked from the palace and sent to a convent where she spent her entire life, first as a novice and then a nun. She did not take vows until she was much older." (I would love to correspond with Lynn Nottage about her research.)

One thing is certain: the Queen would not have given birth privately. There would have been witnesses. Author Catherine Delors has written a wonderful account of Marie Antoinette having to give birth in an all-too-public manner on her blog, Versailles and more, some of which was also posted to Wonders and Marvels, a blog on the 17th century.

Gary McCollim, a historian I often quote here, weighed in on this rumour of a black daughter recently. First, he examined the sources often quoted:
1) Cardinal Dubois was not an eyewitness and he might not have written his memoirs.

2) Voltaire was definitely not an eyewitness. He was born in 1694 and the so-called black daughter was born in 1664.

3) Saint-Simon was not an eyewitness as he was born in 1675.

4) The memoires of the marquise de Montespan were not written by La Montespan but by a male writer after she had died.
5) Thus, the only eyewitness might have been the duchesse de Montpensier, Louis XIV's cousin who was called La Grande Mademoiselle. However, her memoirs only say that the queen gave birth prematurely to a child who was very dark.
We do have some other evidence about this child. Madame, Louis XIV's sister-in-law, wrote that her husband Monsieur who was an eyewitness said that the female child born in 1664 was not black but very ugly. Madame went on to say that no one could get the idea out of people's heads that the child was still alive and was living in a convent at Moret near Fontainebleau. In any case, Madame wrote, it is certain that the ugly child died. All the court had seen her di
Then, we also have copies of letters that Louis XIV wrote to tell the rest of sovereign Europe of the death of his daughter on 26 December 1664.

And finally, we have several sources that report that Louis XIV had a Maurish coachman with a pretty wife. They had a child that the king and queen acted as godparents for. When the child's parents died, Madame de Maintenon had the child put into this convent. As goddaughter to the king and queen, this child might refer to the Dauphin as her brother.
Today, Gary posted more on this mystery after reading a recent biography of Queen Marie Thérèse by Joëlle Chevé:
She discusses the so-called black baby on pages 250-253. Several important facts emerge. First, the baby was born at least one month prematurely. The queen had been sick for several weeks before the child was born. They wanted to giver her last rites which the queen refused because she could not face dying. She would take communion but eventually she agreed to accept the last rites.

In the midst of this long illness, when everyone was wondering what could be done, Madame Foucquet brought a remedy. (Her husband was on trial for his life at the time.) The queen remained ill until January 1665 or two months after the birth of the child Marie-Anne.

Then, Chevé turns to discuss the child who was born under these conditions. Everyone agreed that the child was born with a dark almost violet complexion and a weak constitution. Chevé then cites the memoirs of the Grande Mademoiselle (the duchesse de Montpensier) who was not an eyewitness to the birth but was informed by Monsieur about the child's complexion. When the Grande Mademoiselle did see the child she says that she knew right away that the child was too weak to live.

As to the black nun of Moret, she took the veil in 1695 when the child Marie-Anne, had she lived, would have been thirty years old. This is a late age for taking the veil. Chevé doubts that the black nun was thirty years old. When the rumors began circulating that the black nun was in fact the child Marie-Anne, Madame de Maintenon tried to squelch them by saying that she had put the girl in the convent as a favor for the girl's parents who were Moors who worked in the King's Menagerie.
As for me, I'm still uncertain. As with births, the death of a child was also public. Why are there no accounts?

(The image of Marie Antoinette's public birthing is taken from Catherine's blog.)

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Plot and research concerns from a reader

I answered emails from readers on the week-end. One I got was a first for me: a serious response to my struggles with research (as posted on this blog) and what that means with respect to my plot. He (or she: I don't know) expressed concern that I was headed in the wrong direction for The Next Novel. With permission, I'm quoting the letter in full:
As a fan of your writing, I should probably have some faith that the Next Novel is going to be great, regardless of how you decide to organize the plot. Here are some of my thoughts on this, given in a constructive, rather than critical, tone, all in the hope of allowing you to consider a fan's perspective as you start making important decisions about the plot.

Novelists, even ones who are rigorous about the facts, have an obligation, first and foremost, to telling a good story. I could be wrong, but it seems to me that re-imagining the Affair of the Poisons as a petty frame-job executed by Louvois -- rather than a dastardly plot against the throne itself, carried out by a royal mistress KNOWN to have been a villain in many regards -- kind of lets the air out of a potentially epic story of love and betrayal. After all, what's more scintillating: Satanism within the gilded halls of Versailles or the 17th Century equivalent of watercooler politics?

Now, maybe you're resistant to someone urging you to downplay the facts for the sake of telling a good story. But that's not really what I'm doing. In fact, I question whether the facts are really pointing you in the direction you think.

Lemoine's argument about Louvois being the driving force behind the Poisons scandal seems to be contradicted by the pleas of many other historians who've concluded that Montespan really was guilty of some vile deeds. Sure, few modern scholars believe that she tried to murder the king, as that was against her interests. But why is it so difficult to believe that Montespan was psychologically incapable of poisoning Fontanges, a rival for the king's affection? Montespan's contemporaries describe her behavior as increasingly erratic -- violence, mood swings, temper tantrums, eating binges, gambling binges -- with each passing year in which she was the king's mistress. The marquise certainly acted like a guilty person after retiring from Versailles, exhibiting a terrible fear of the afterlife.

In an earlier post, you mentioned that you were having trouble with the Next Novel because it was difficult to write from Claude's point of view if one assumes she was a knowing accomplice to murder. I hope your attraction to the Louvois angle isn't rooted in the fact that it effectively absolves Claude to some degree and therefore makes her more sympathetic as a lead character. The fact is, you CAN write sympathetically from Claude's perspective, even if she was an accomplice to murder!

Here's how I see what happened in Claude's life: She was a fundamentally good, if slightly too impressionable, girl who got mixed up in something that was wrong. Many books have characters that resist the temptation to do wrong. But many great novels also feature characters who succumb to what is wrong, and live to be haunted by their deeds. I think we can all identify with that, right? It also happens to be more of a morally strong, perhaps even literary approach, than conceiving yet another female character who finds herself entirely the victim of other people's machinations.

When you think about it, there's even reason to sympathize, slightly, with La Montespan. Pampered, exalted, steeped in luxury and yet -- in a deep, subconscious place the haughty marquise wouldn't admit to anyone -- afraid of losing her treasured lifestyle to a rival, it's easy to see why she might have gone a little bonkers.

Anyway, as you find your way through the conceptual terrain of this novel, please keep these things in mind! Characters that make terrible decisions aren't necessarily unsympathetic! It just depends on how you tell their stories! Good luck, Sandra!
I love getting such a well-written letter from a knowledgeable reader, and I very much agree with this reader that story is the most important thing. As a writer, I do "massage" the historical record for the sake of story, but it's hard to write passionately about something for years and years if I don't think it's true ... or, at the least, that I think it likely true, at least from my understanding of the research.

Part of my personal motivation for writing about history is to explore that reality. But what is the reality? According to many historians, both Claude and Athénaïs are guilty. According to one significant historian (Petitfils) Athénaïs is innocent, but Claude is guilty. According to Lemoine, both Athénaïs and Claude are likely innocent. As I said on my writing blog, I may not really know what I think about all this until I'm into the bowels of the very last draft, years from now.

I do want the reader not to worry, however: the twists and turns of this story will make for extremely dramatic reading, no mater what kaleidoscope one is looking through!
image